Preload Spinner

Moving Up in St. John’s: Do You Need a Separate Dining Room?

BACK

Moving Up in St. John’s: Do You Need a Separate Dining Room?

Aerial view of homes, trees and the coastline beside Conception Bay

If a separate dining room is on your move-up wish list, ask what problem you want it to solve before ruling out homes without one. Do you need somewhere to host a crowd, a table that can stay set, or simply enough space for everyone to sit down together?

Those are different needs. Your next St. John’s Metro home should support the way your household eats and gathers, rather than just include the room name you expected to find.

Separate the ordinary week from the special occasion

Write down what happens around your table during a normal week. Include meals, homework, working from home and anything that needs to be cleared away before supper. Then make a separate note of the larger gatherings you genuinely want to accommodate.

If you host regularly, a dedicated room may earn its place. If the biggest gathering happens only occasionally, compare how much you would use that room between events. Neither answer is wrong; the useful question is which tradeoff you want to make.

Test the furniture arrangement, not just the empty floor

Bring the measurements of the table and any furniture you hope to keep. Sketch where they would sit, and look at how people would enter, leave and move past occupied chairs. A room can look generous without a table and still feel awkward once you picture your own arrangement.

Do not assume a listing photograph proves your furniture will fit. With permission, take the measurements you need during a viewing. If an important dimension is uncertain, record it as a question instead of estimating it from a wide-angle picture.

Follow the route from the kitchen

Imagine carrying supper to the table, bringing dishes back and putting serving items away. Look at the doors, corners and other routes that share the space. Is the dining area also the path to the patio, the main hallway or another room?

For an open layout, consider whether you like seeing the kitchen while eating or hosting. For a separate room, consider whether you want that separation during everyday meals. This is about your preference, not a rule that one layout is better.

Give shared spaces an honest job description

If the table will also be a homework station or work surface, decide where those items go when the room changes use. An attractive second table is not much help if both become permanent storage.

Ask everyone who uses the space what currently frustrates them. The answer may be a bigger table, somewhere for school supplies, or a quieter place for calls. A separate dining room only solves the problem if the rest of the plan makes those activities workable.

Compare the whole move-up decision

For each home, write one sentence describing what its dining arrangement gives you and one describing what you would give up. Compare that against the rooms, location and other features that matter to your household. Avoid giving a dining room extra weight simply because it photographs well.

CMHC’s Homebuying Step by Step resources provide a broader guide and workbook for organizing your buying priorities. Keep your own daily routines beside that checklist.

Use my move-up layout guide for the wider floor plan, and the second-viewing checklist to organize the details you still need to confirm.

Moving up in St. John’s, Mount Pearl, Paradise or CBS? Call or text Ryan Elliott at 709-687-7726. Tell me what your current dining space cannot do, and let’s focus your search around a useful improvement.